84-Year-Old Woman Back to Work at Dollar Tree After $300K Social Security Loss
In a startling twist of fate, an 84-year-old woman has been compelled to return to the workforce due to two federal policies that have drastically altered her financial landscape. Meet Evelyn Paternostro, a resilient soul from Louisiana, who now finds herself serving as a part-time cashier at Dollar Tree—just to keep food on her table.
After dedicating decades to teaching and serving as a principal, Evelyn now grapples with the harsh reality of financial insecurity. Thanks to a convoluted Social Security regulation, she has been forced out of retirement—a system that was supposed to provide for her has instead turned her life upside down.
With a wistful glance, she shares her experience: “People at the store ask me all the time, ‘Are you doing this for fun? Why aren’t you retired?’” Her answer, starkly honest, is simple: “Because I need to eat.”
Tragic as it may be, Evelyn’s plight isn’t uncommon. After the loss of her spouse, she discovered that federal policies were preventing her from collecting his Social Security benefits. The Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) and the Government Pension Offset (GPO) have left countless public servants like her struggling to make ends meet.
Understanding WEP and GPO
The Windfall Elimination Provision and the Government Pension Offset have been relics of the system for almost 40 years.
- Windfall Elimination Provision: Affects those who receive a pension from non-Social Security work and have additional income from Social Security, typically slashing benefits by up to 50%.
- Government Pension Offset: Targets individuals who qualify for spousal Social Security benefits while collecting a pension from non-Social Security jobs, potentially wiping out their spousal benefits entirely.
These provisions affect around 3 million Americans—particularly educators, firefighters, police officers, and other public servants who have devoted their careers to serving their communities. “I was really blindsided,” Evelyn recounts. “I never truly considered how my husband’s income would impact my future.”
The WEP and GPO were implemented in the 1980s to prevent individuals from “double-dipping” benefits from both a federal pension and Social Security. Nevertheless, they have inadvertently left many like Evelyn in dire straits.
As a result, she estimates she has lost out on approximately $2,500 per month in spousal benefits—totaling around $300,000 over the past decade. “That’s a lot of money,” she laments. “It feels like this money has been stolen from us. It’s just not fair.”
Steps Towards Reform
In response to the growing outcry against these inequities, the Social Security Fairness Act was introduced, aiming to repeal the WEP and GPO. Advocates for this change, including several representatives, argue that it’s time to rectify the injustice inflicted upon public servants who have selflessly dedicated their lives to their communities.
After years of advocacy, the Social Security Fairness Act was passed by Congress on December 21, 2024, and now awaits the President’s signature to become law. Yet, the path forward remains contentious, with critics voicing concerns about the potential financial implications of such a repeal, especially as Social Security faces its own funding challenges.
“Critics suggest this could cost around $200 billion over the next decade,” explains an analyst. “We need comprehensive solutions, not just quick fixes.”
As more stories like Evelyn’s emerge, the conversation around Social Security becomes increasingly urgent. Americans across the nation share their frustrations, with many feeling robbed by a system designed to protect and support them in their golden years. One woman, aged 65, expressed her dismay, stating, “They have stolen from me” after discovering she is owed $500,000 due to lost benefits over the years.
3
This is a call to action, America! As we reflect on the stories of individuals like Evelyn Paternostro, it’s time to advocate for fairness in the Social Security system and ensure that our beloved public servants receive the respect and support they deserve during their retirement years.
