How My Dream Home Turned into a Budget Nightmare: My Shocking Journey!

Welcome to Pay Dirt, your go-to source for financial wisdom! Got a burning question? Share it with our experts today! (Totally anonymous!)

Dear Pay Dirt,

I’m a 34-year-old guy who teamed up with my close friend Jae, a 36-year-old nonbinary individual, four years ago to buy a house. At that point, neither of us expected to be in serious romantic relationships, so it felt like our best shot at home ownership. Fast forward two years, and I’ve now met the love of my life, Elle.

Elle and I are over the moon together, discussing marriage and dreaming about kids—all within the next couple of years! But here’s the kicker: we want to move in together, and that’s where things get tricky. While Elle gets along with Jae, let’s just say they wouldn’t choose to be friends without me in the mix. Elle loves our friendship, but having another adult in the house while raising a child? That’s a hard pass for her. Plus, Jae isn’t a fan of kids, and Elle can’t stand Jae’s decorating style. Talk about a recipe for disaster!

Currently, Elle’s renting a cozy one-bedroom but has enough saved to contribute half the down payment on a house. She’s expressed interest in buying Jae’s share of our home, but Jae is emotionally attached to it and refuses to move. The dilemma? Jae’s equity isn’t enough to get a comparable place, and selling my half is proving to be a nightmare. Finding a buyer who Jae would be comfortable living with is a tall order. Jae, bless their heart, is wonderfully unique but incredibly particular. How on earth do I navigate this maze?

—Trapped

Dear Trapped,

I totally get why you feel like you’re caught between a rock and a hard place. Mixing friendships and finances is no walk in the park, especially when it involves two significant relationships. But hold tight—there are options, even if they require some major compromises.

Have you thought about bringing in a roommate? This could ease some financial pressure and help you manage the cost of living. Renting out your half might give you some breathing room, although it’s only a temporary fix and doesn’t address the down payment issue. Plus, I can see how Jae might feel uneasy sharing their space with a stranger.

What if Jae can’t buy you out right now? Consider a gradual buyout agreement where payments could be made over time. It’s not a quick solution but could work if you’re committed to this path. You might also need to collaborate financially with Elle. What if she covered a larger chunk of the down payment while you took on more of the mortgage initially? Alternatively, what if you both slowed down on buying a new home and opted to rent for a while?

Since Elle is keen on purchasing Jae’s share, let’s explore that route. She could buy Jae’s portion, giving Jae a set timeframe to secure a new place. Just remember, this could throw a wrench in your plans with Elle and could complicate your relationship dynamics.

In a perfect world, it would be ideal for both you and Jae to sell the house and split the equity. But I understand how attached Jae is to the home. Present them with viable alternatives; they might see that selling is the most straightforward path forward. It’s also vital to consult a financial advisor to clarify your options and find the best solution for everyone involved.

Have an open and empathetic conversation with Jae about their feelings. Let them know how much you value the friendship and the home, but also emphasize the importance of your future with Elle. Reassure them that you’re committed to maintaining the friendship throughout this transition.

Dear Pay Dirt,

My partner and I are deeply in love and excited about merging our lives. While we chat about marriage, we’re not entirely convinced it’s essential at this point. We both own homes and earn good incomes, but he has kids, which complicates things as we consider moving in together and blending finances. Plus, his house is located in an area that’s more suitable for family life, which means I’d have to give up my charming spot in a much cooler neighborhood to make it work.

How do we navigate this? I’ve heard it’s a mistake to invest in equity that isn’t mine. Ideally, we want to buy a place together, but that means selling one or both homes first—and the housing market isn’t exactly cooperative. He just bought his house last year, so moving out now doesn’t seem wise. My place has a decade of equity and a low mortgage, while his location is less desirable and has a higher interest rate. How do couples manage this without one partner feeling like they’re losing out? Should I sell my home, rent it out, or draft a contract? Help!

—Two Many Houses

Dear Two Many,

Seeking advice from a financial planner is crucial here. I know it sounds a bit dull, but they can tailor a plan specific to your situation that works for both of you.

Given that you both own property, keeping both homes for now might be the smartest move. Renting out your house could be the most viable option, but if taxes are a concern, a financial planner can guide you through potential implications. This approach allows you to buy time without making hasty decisions about selling, especially when you have a low mortgage rate.

Once you decide to move in, you’ll have to determine how much each of you will contribute to the mortgage. Instead of covering the mortgage, consider taking responsibility for other bills. It’s true that investing in someone else’s equity isn’t ideal, but you’ll also be generating rental income from your property. A “cohabitation agreement” might be incredibly useful—it could outline how you’ll split expenses, handle mortgage contributions, and divide equity if one of you sells. It’ll protect both of you and help clarify expectations.

There’s no universal answer, which is why working with a planner is essential. They’ll help you work out the finer details and create a written agreement. It might seem excessive, but having it in writing can provide both of you with the peace of mind to move forward confidently.

Craving more Pay Dirt? Slate Plus members enjoy an extra column each week! Join Slate Plus today!

Dear Pay Dirt,

My new home only has partial fencing in the back for privacy, and the side facing the carport is open to the driveway. I prioritized replacing the deck and bathroom since I only have three lazy indoor cats.

My sister, an overly enthusiastic dog owner, has a habit of bringing her dog everywhere—even going as far as to purchase a fake service dog vest! Despite my repeated requests for her to leave her dog at home, my family has sided with her.

After moving in, I bluntly told my sister that it wasn’t safe for her dog given the busy street I live on. When my mother came over to watch my cats for the weekend, she brought my sister and her dog, which then escaped and was grazed by a car. I returned home to a flurry of missed calls, fearing the worst, only to have my sister unleash her anger about vet bills and blaming me for the situation. I told her she was reckless and deserved to face the consequences of her actions. Now, I’m skipping family gatherings to avoid her incessant complaints.

My brother has now jumped in, claiming my house is “unsafe” for his kids. I’ve stayed silent but am close to telling him that if his kids think playing in traffic is a good time, he has bigger parenting issues. As a first-time homeowner, this should be a joyful achievement, but I’m at a loss for how to proceed. What should I do—just cut ties with my family?

—Stay in the Yard

Dear Stay,

You told your sister she should be punished? That’s a tough one to overlook. I understand your frustration with your family for not respecting your boundaries and then blaming you for the fallout. However, that reaction—threats and insults—might be a bit extreme.

It seems your family might be siding with your sister due to the way you’ve reacted to the situation. Taking a break from family dynamics might be a wise choice. Consider talking to a therapist to help process your feelings and identify any underlying issues that might be contributing to your anger.

In the future, try to communicate your boundaries without resorting to threats. You could explain that your home isn’t safe for dogs or children, and if they insist on bringing them over, they may need to sign a waiver. While that may feel extreme, it could underscore the seriousness of the situation. Ultimately, if your family continues to add stress to your life, stepping back to address deeper issues might be the healthiest approach for everyone involved.

—Kristin

Classic Prudie

I’m about to give birth to my second child, and I want to prevent my in-laws from ruining this experience like they did the first time. When my son was born two years ago, they met him via FaceTime due to hospital restrictions. They received a message with his full name and details an hour ahead of time, which should have been extremely exciting since he was their first grandchild.